Molly's Pizzeria

Discover Molly's Pizzeria in Chillicothe, IL, offering delicious buffet options, flavorful calzones, wings, vegan choices, breadsticks, and topped pizzas. Call +1 309-270-8600 for great prices and tasty favorites like pulled pork nachos and more!

Welcome to Molly's Pizzeria

Signature Dining Experience

Molly's Pizzeria
Molly's Pizzeria
Molly's Pizzeria
Molly's Pizzeria

Molly's Pizzeria serves as a local gem in Chillicothe, Illinois, inviting pizza lovers to indulge in a diverse array of dishes. Located at 223 Cedar St, this cozy spot offers a welcoming atmosphere perfect for families and friends. Known for its delicious buffet, patrons appreciate the variety of toppings and styles. The standout options include calzones, hand-tossed pizzas, wings, and even vegan delights. Unique items like pulled pork nachos and the Garbage Can pizza add a fun twist to traditional favorites. Whether dining in or grabbing takeout, the flavors at Molly's Pizzeria leave a lasting impression.

Location & Contact

Address

223 Cedar St, Chillicothe, IL 61523, United States

Phone

+1 309-270-8600

Social Media

About

Molly's Pizzeria
Molly's Pizzeria
Molly's Pizzeria
Molly's Pizzeria

Molly's Pizzeria is not just any pizza joint; it's a cornerstone of the Chillicothe community, where friends and families gather to enjoy their favorite meals. Established with the belief that great food brings people together, this eatery offers a diverse menu tailored to please everyone’s palate. Guests often rave about the extensive buffet, packed with possibilities—from calzones bursting with flavor to classic pizzas made with the freshest ingredients. The casual dining vibe creates a friendly atmosphere, perfect for celebrations or casual weeknight dinners.

Regulars appreciate the value without compromising on quality; the signature Garbage Can pizza presents a fun, sharable option for groups. It's beneficial to note busy hours; Friday nights at 6 PM reach full capacity, indicating the restaurant’s popularity. Exploring less busy times, such as Wednesday afternoons, can lead to a more relaxed dining experience. The restaurant embraces a community spirit, often participating in local events and encouraging customers to contribute to community initiatives. A carefully curated selection of vegan options allows Molly's Pizzeria to accommodate diverse dietary preferences.

Plus, the desserts, including delectable chocolate chip cannolis and apple pie calzones, provide a sweet end to any meal. Over the years, Molly's has maintained a reputation for consistency, ensuring patrons return for their beloved dishes. The personal touch from the staff enhances the overall dining experience, making it a favorite for many in Chillicothe. As a staple in the area, Molly's Pizzeria continues to evolve while staying true to its roots and loyal customer base, making it a must-visit destination for anyone in the vicinity.

Work Hours

  • Sunday12-7 PM
  • Monday11 AM-8 PM
  • TuesdayClosed
  • Wednesday11 AM-9 PM
  • Thursday11 AM-8 PM
  • Friday11 AM-9 PM
  • Saturday11 AM-9 PM

A vibrant buffet spreads across the counter, showcasing several unique pizzas and mouthwatering appetizers. The menu boasts a selection of over 139 dishes, including everything from crispy fried mushrooms to savory calzones. Guests can relish customized pizzas with a wide variety of toppings or indulge in specialty pies like the Bacon Cheeseburger or the Cedar Street. Families love the kid-friendly options—think chicken strips and mac & cheese—while adults often savor hearty sandwiches or fresh salads. With an average dish price of $12, Molly's Pizzeria combines value with flavor. Plan visits around peak hours, as Fridays can draw large crowds, making the seats fill quickly.

Molly's Pizzeria

Molly's Pizzeria presents a classic facade, welcoming patrons with its comfortable and inviting exterior. Situated on Cedar Street, it blends seamlessly with the local architecture, making it an easy find for newcomers and returnees alike. Visitors often enjoy the casual atmosphere both inside and outside, with picnic-style seating and easy access for families. The vibrant colors and eye-catching signage reflect the energetic vibe within, inviting diners to come in and savor the delicious offerings. The outdoor seating area offers a great spot to enjoy nice weather while indulging in a slice or two.

Customer Reviews

Great pizza, plenty of toppings, friendly staff, nice atmosphere and vibe, reasonable prices, great place to stop in for pizza and more! We tried a half and half Hawaiian and their version of meat lovers. Good stuff!

B
Brian J.

OMG! The pizza was SO GOOD! The crust was the best I've tasted. The options for toppings were vast, and the specialty pizzas were very unique and tasty. Will definitely be back. Maybe I'll try out the lunch buffet.

E
Elizabeth B.

Best pizza and wings around! The new salad bar set up with the pizza buffet is AMAZINGLY good!!!! The owner and staff take extremely good care of making sure the entire establishment is MEGA clean. The kitchen area is rated on my top 3 of the CLEANEST kitchens I've been in. If great food, great service and an extremely clean establishment is priority on your list, I highly recommend Molly's in Chillicothe.

B
Brandon L.

One of the best pizzas I've had in a long time. I had the hand tossed crust. Lots of topping and cheese. Great home-made crust. My wife had the Gluten Free crust and she said it was great! Tried some of the appetizers as well and they were all delicious, wings were exceptional.. We will be coming back here soon

S
Steve W.

Stopped in for lunch on Sunday and found the place slammed by the after-church crowd. Nonetheless the manager got us (2) in at the bar and rushed our simple pie and drink order ahead of the table of 14. Had the 8"classic and iced tea. The pizza was delicious. More than plenty of toppings and tasty. Hand tossed crust had a little crunch to the bottom and a nice chewy edge. Updated 11/24/24: called in a pizza order from the road, 8" Classic ftw! The feature that stood out was the lack of grease. That's not to say that there wasn't any, but you know how some of those chain pizza places use meats and cheese that leave the pizza box waterproof? Not a problem with my takeout. Just great pizza - will be back the next time travel brings me through. Have to mention the "garage door windows", very nice.

A
At A.

From when you first enter Mollys the atmosphere is very pleasant. And then you're greeted with a very warm welcome. Katie was our server, she did an excellent job! The pizza, as you can see all the toppings came clear to the edge of the pizza and plenty of sauce. Which is very hard to find these days. The pizza was excellent. This place definitely earned my five stars. We will definitely be making a trip back to Molly's pizzeria. Thank your WEEK TV 25 for steering us towards this place.

G
Greg D.